Texas Penal Code § 38.04: Evading Arrest or Detention (Overview)

You’re driving down a Texas backroad when flashing lights hit your mirror, and you hesitate, unsure of what to do. Next thing you know, you’re being charged under Texas Penal Code § 38.04 for evading arrest or detention. It’s a serious offense that can quickly escalate from a misunderstanding to a life-altering felony, especially if a vehicle is involved.

If you or someone you care about is facing this charge, you’re likely asking, What exactly does the law say? What penalties could apply? And are there any defenses? Below, we answer those questions in clear, practical terms.

What Is Texas Penal Code § 38.04?

It’s the state law that defines evading arrest or detention as intentionally fleeing from a peace officer or federal special investigator lawfully attempting to arrest or detain you. This means that prosecutors must prove three elements:

• Knowledge. You knew or reasonably should have known the person pursuing you was a law enforcement officer.
• Intent. You intentionally fled. It was not a mistake where you misunderstood instructions or otherwise failed to stop with no attempt to flee or evade officers.
• Legal attempt. The officer was attempting a lawful arrest or detention.

An evading charge applies whether you’re running, in a vehicle, or even trying to escape during a traffic stop. The method of evasion directly affects the level of the offense.

Is Evading Arrest a Felony in Texas?

Such a charge can be a felony in Texas. The severity varies based on the circumstances of the evasion and any prior offenses. The prosecutor classifies the charge as follows:

• Class A misdemeanor—if you evade on foot and it’s your first offense;
• State jail felony—if you have a prior evading conviction or use a vehicle while evading;
• Third-degree felony—if another person suffers serious bodily injury as a direct result of the evasion (e.g., if a vehicle crash ensues); or
• Second-degree felony—if the evasion causes death.

Using a vehicle, especially in high-speed situations, can elevate the charge to a felony, even if no one suffers injuries.

What Counts As Evading Arrest in a Motor Vehicle?

Under Texas law, evading arrest in your car, motorcycle, or other vehicle is not a separate charge but elevates a regular evading arrest offense to a state jail felony or worse, depending on the facts. A few common scenarios include:

• Failing to pull over during a traffic stop when clearly signaled,
• Speeding off when police lights activate behind you, or
• Taking evasive turns or driving erratically to avoid being stopped.

Texas courts often view even brief car pursuits as serious attempts to evade law enforcement. Prosecutors only need to demonstrate that you intentionally avoided stopping, without needing to prove your involvement in another offense.

Regardless of how the evasion occurred, the consequences can be severe.

Penalties for Evading Arrest or Detention

Here’s how the punishments break down:

• Class A Misdemeanor—up to 1 year in jail and a fine of up to $4,000;
• State jail felony—180 days to 2 years in a state jail facility and a fine of up to $10,000;
• Third-degree felony—2 to 10 years in prison and a fine up to $10,000; and
• Second-degree felony—2 to 20 years in prison and a fine up to $10,000.

These penalties don’t include collateral consequences like license suspension, probation terms, or complications for immigration and employment.

Common Defenses to an Evading Charge

Depending on the specific circumstances, several common defense strategies can be applicable:

• No intent to flee. You genuinely didn’t realize the officer was signaling you to stop, or you had a valid reason for your actions. Valid reasons can include such things as an emergency, fear, or a medical issue.
• Mistaken identity. You were not the individual driving or fleeing, and law enforcement made a visual or procedural error.
• Lack of knowledge. You were unaware that the pursuer was law enforcement, especially in situations involving unmarked vehicles.
• Unlawful arrest or detention. If the initial stop was unlawful, any subsequent evasion charge might not be sustainable. For example, if the officer didn’t have a reasonable suspicion of criminal activity to justify the stop or if they did not have probable cause to arrest you, your lawyer could file a Motion to Suppress resultant critical evidence.

Your attorney may also explore constitutional violations related to how evidence was gathered or whether your rights were respected during the stop.

Can Evading Arrest Be Dismissed?

Yes, but dismissal depends heavily on the facts, your record, and the jurisdiction. Prosecutors may consider:

• First-time offense status;
• Lack of aggravating factors, like injury or property damage;
• Strong defense arguments or mitigation, such as medical episodes; and
• Successful completion of diversion programs.

An experienced attorney may be able to negotiate for dismissal, deferred adjudication, a reduction in charges, or other favorable outcomes. That’s why taking the charge seriously from day one is crucial.

Take the On Your Evasion Charge with Austin Hagee Law Firm

Attorney Austin Hagee brings a sharp trial background as a former Bexar County prosecutor. He’s handled evading arrest cases from both sides of the courtroom, giving clients an edge. The firm’s approach is focused, respectful, and strategic. Whether your case involves an on-foot incident or a high-speed pursuit, Austin Hagee Law Firm can help you challenge the evidence, explore all legal options, and fight for a better path forward. Let’s talk about what comes next. Contact us by calling at 726-223-6041.

Resources

• Penal Code Offenses by Range. Texas Attorney General, link.

The Evading Arrest Statute. Texas District & County Attorneys Association (TDCAA), link.

Austin Hagee

Austin M. Hagee is a trusted and proven San Antonio trial lawyer who tirelessly defends his clients’ constitutional rights. As a former prosecutor turned nationally recognized criminal defense attorney, Austin has the knowledge and expertise to get the best possible outcome for his clients.

Rate this Post

Loading...